# Choosing steel for a knife

> How to choose a knife steel by the job and your workshop, how the properties trade against each other, and a page for each of thirteen steels.

Source: https://knifetemplates.com/steel

[Learn](https://knifetemplates.com/guides) / Steel

It is easy to get lost in steel comparisons before you have drawn a knife. My starting point is simpler: what will the knife do, and can you heat treat that steel properly with the setup you have?

[Knife Templates](https://knifetemplates.com/makers/knife-templates) · 6 min read

## Start with the knife

Selecting a steel is about prioritising the categories: toughness, edge retention and corrosion resistance. Usually more of one means less of the other. A kitchen knife that is washed and dried asks different things of the steel from a chopper that gets dropped in mud.

And keep the steel in proportion: "a great steel and heat treatment can't save a bad design."

## Then your workshop

The first page under Choosing between steels is a picker. It narrows the steels by the equipment you have, whether you need stainless and what your knife is for, using only what the sources say.

A steel that suits the knife is no use if you cannot treat it. If you cannot hold a temperature accurately, the fallback for torch and uncontrolled forge heat treating is 1075/1084. With a controlled furnace and a fast oil, the low alloy steels here (1095, 80CrV2, 5160, 52100, 8670 and O1) are all open to you.

D2 and the stainless steels ask for far more: furnaces holding anywhere from about 1850°F up to 2050°F, quench plates and, in most of these routes, a cold treatment. They also rule out the forge, because "Basically any steel with 3% chromium or more" is unsuitable for the tested forge method.

### Choosing between steels

- [Which steel should your knife be?](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/which-steel)

  Narrow the steels by your equipment, stainless or not, and your knife.
- [1084 or 1095?](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/1084-vs-1095)

  Two plain carbon steels: the equipment each asks for and the toughness each showed in testing.
- [5160 or 80CrV2?](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/5160-vs-80crv2)

  Two low alloy working-knife steels: toughness, tempering limits and edge life, from separate tests.
- [AEB-L or MagnaCut?](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/aeb-l-vs-magnacut)

  Two stainless steels: composition, the properties each source reports, and what the routes ask of you.
- [1075, 1080, 15N20, 26C3 and W2](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/simple-carbon-steels)

  Five simple carbon steels, what the sources say about each, and where they disagree.

## The thirteen steels, side by side

This is what each worked route asks of the maker. It is not a ranking, and the figures in the routes are examples to establish on a coupon, not promises.

*What each worked route asks of the maker*

| Steel | Kind | Stainless | Quench | Protection | Cold step |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1084 | Plain carbon | No | Fast oil (Parks 50) | Anti-scale protection | None in this route |
| 1095 | Plain carbon | No | Fast oil (Parks 50) | Anti-scale coating | None in this route |
| 80CrV2 | Low alloy | No | Oil, fast or medium | Surface protection | None in this route |
| 5160 | Low alloy spring steel | No | Medium-speed oil (Parks AAA) | Anti-scale protection | None in this route |
| 52100 | Low alloy bearing steel | No | Fast oil (Parks 50) | Surface protection | None in this route |
| O1 | Oil-hardening tool steel | No | Oil, no brand named | Surface protection | None in this route |
| AEB-L | Stainless | Yes | Aluminium plates and compressed air | Foil packet | Sub-zero treatment |
| CPM MagnaCut | Stainless, powder metallurgy | Yes | Quench plates | Foil or atmosphere protection | None in this route |
| 8670 | Low alloy, high toughness | No | Fast or medium oil (Parks AAA or Parks 50) | Surface protection | None in this route |
| D2 | High-chromium tool steel | No | Plate quench | Stainless wrap or other protection | Liquid nitrogen or dry ice |
| Nitro-V | Stainless | Yes | Plate quench | Not covered by the source | Liquid nitrogen, or a freezer straight after the quench |
| S35VN | Stainless, powder metallurgy | Yes | Plate quench | Not covered by the source | Liquid nitrogen, at least 30 minutes |
| CPM-154 | Stainless, powder metallurgy | Yes | Plate quench between aluminium plates | Stainless foil | Liquid nitrogen |

### A page for each steel

- [Knife steel: 1084](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/1084)

  A plain carbon steel, the usual fallback when the heat is hard to control.
- [Knife steel: 1095](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/1095)

  A simple high-carbon steel with lower toughness than its reputation suggests.
- [Knife steel: 80CrV2](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/80crv2)

  A low alloy steel with good toughness and hardenability, but low wear resistance.
- [Knife steel: 5160](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/5160)

  A low alloy spring steel known for toughness, with a narrow tempering window.
- [Knife steel: 52100](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/52100)

  A non-stainless bearing steel with good toughness and a fine edge.
- [Knife steel: O1](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/o1)

  An oil-hardening tool steel that needs a long, controlled soak.
- [Knife steel: AEB-L](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/aeb-l)

  A tough, fine-grained stainless steel whose route needs foil, plates and a cold step.
- [Knife steel: CPM MagnaCut](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/cpm-magnacut)

  A powder metallurgy stainless steel with the producer's own figures, and the caveats on them.
- [Knife steel: 8670](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/8670)

  A tough nickel-chromium low alloy steel with an easy heat treatment and low wear resistance.
- [Knife steel: D2](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/d2)

  A high-carbon, high-chromium tool steel that is not stainless and wants a cold step.
- [Knife steel: Nitro-V](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/nitro-v)

  A nitrogen-alloyed relative of AEB-L with very good toughness and some untested claims.
- [Knife steel: S35VN](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/s35vn)

  A balanced powder metallurgy stainless steel, tougher and easier to grind than S30V.
- [Knife steel: CPM-154](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/cpm-154)

  A well-rounded powder metallurgy stainless steel, easy to finish, with a toughness result that is still unexplained.

## The ideas behind the choice

These pages explain what the properties are, how they are measured, why they trade against each other, and what the steel families are.

### How steel works

- [What is in knife steel](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/what-is-in-knife-steel)

  Carbides, chromium and stainless, and the trade-offs between toughness and wear.
- [Toughness, edge retention and corrosion resistance](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/toughness-edge-retention-corrosion)

  What the three properties are, how they are measured, and why they trade.
- [Carbon, stainless, tool and powder metallurgy steels](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/carbon-stainless-tool-and-powder)

  The steel families and what each asks of the maker.
- [Identifying stock steel](https://knifetemplates.com/steel/identifying-stock-steel)

  Spark test patterns, and why unidentified stock stays an experiment.

## What I am leaving out

There are far more than thirteen knife steels. I have added the ones I can source properly, and I would rather have thirteen pages I stand behind than forty I do not. I also do not rank steels: the advice from the metallurgy sources is to ignore rating articles, and even published ratings carry a reservation that they may change with new information. I treat them as one metallurgist's judgement.

### Then heat treat it

- [How to heat treat a knife](https://knifetemplates.com/heat-treating)

  The stages in order, the ways to do them, and a worked route for each steel.

## Where this comes from

- [How to Pick the Best Steel for Every Knife](https://knifesteelnerds.com/2019/05/20/how-to-pick-the-best-steel-for-every-knife/), Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s method for choosing a steel, with his own recommendations. Opinion informed by his testing; the charts are images.
- [Knife Steels Rated by a Metallurgist: Toughness, Edge Retention, and Corrosion Resistance](https://knifesteelnerds.com/2021/10/19/knife-steels-rated-by-a-metallurgist-toughness-edge-retention-and-corrosion-resistance/), Knife Steel Nerds. One metallurgist’s ratings, which he says he may change. The rating tables are images, so this site quotes only the text.
- [How to Heat Treat Knife Steel in a Forge](https://knifesteelnerds.com/2021/09/23/how-to-heat-treat-knife-steel-in-a-forge/), Knife Steel Nerds. A method for reducing forge error, tested on seven low alloy steels. The author still recommends a furnace or a professional for most people.
- [CPM MagnaCut data sheet, issue 1, March 2021](https://www.alphaknifesupply.com/Pictures/Info/Steel/CPMMagnaCut-DS.pdf), Crucible Industries. The producer’s own composition, toughness, edge retention, annealing and heat treatment figures. Producer data, not independent testing.

## Elsewhere in Learn

- [How to heat treat a knife](https://knifetemplates.com/heat-treating)
- [Rockwell hardness (HRC) for knives](https://knifetemplates.com/guides/makers/8fa87d84-80ef-4b2d-8883-d5ed4c40d125)
- [All guides](https://knifetemplates.com/guides)

## Put it into practice

[Choose a template](https://knifetemplates.com/templates) [Read the print guide](https://knifetemplates.com/guides/print-at-actual-size) [Arrange blanks on stock](https://knifetemplates.com/nest)
