The number everyone quotes
Hardness is the number on almost every knife listing. Larrin Thomas, the metallurgist behind Knife Steel Nerds, compares it to megapixels in cameras: it became an easy marketing point because it is a simple number to present to the public. A single figure is easy to compare, and it is also easy to misread.
Rockwell C is the scale used for hardened knife steel. You will see it written as HRC or as Rc, they mean the same thing. This guide is about what that reading tells you when you are making a knife, and what it doesn't.
How a reading is made
Wikipedia's article on the Rockwell scale describes the test. A diamond cone with a 120 degree included angle and a tip radius of 0.200 mm presses into the steel. A light load of 10 kgf is applied first, to set a zero position. Then the main load of 150 kgf is applied and removed, and the machine measures how much deeper the cone went than the zero position. Deeper means softer.
For the C scale the reading is 100 minus 500 times the depth in millimetres. By that formula, one point of HRC is two thousandths of a millimetre, or two microns, of depth. A 60 HRC steel leaves a dent only about 0.08 mm deep. I worked that out from Wikipedia's formula, so check it yourself if the figure matters, but it explains why a rough surface or a wobbly test piece gives a poor reading.
Testing a blade properly
The conditions that matter for a knife:
- A flat surface, square to the indenter. Convex surfaces read low. A ground bevel is not a good place to test.
- Enough thickness. The test piece should be at least 10 times as thick as the dent is deep. At 60 HRC that is roughly 0.8 mm, again by my arithmetic from the same formula. A thin edge doesn't meet that, so test a thicker flat part of the blade or a test piece, not the edge.
- A reading in range. Readings below about HRC 20 are generally considered unreliable on this scale, which doesn't matter for a hardened blade but matters if you test a blade that has not hardened.
Grind through any scale and through the surface layer to bright steel before testing, the surface can be softer than the steel under it. Use a machine that has been checked against a certified test block, and take several readings and look at how far they spread. A file skating across a blade is a rough check, not an HRC measurement, it can't tell you the number.
What hardness does tell you
Hardness is a reasonable stand-in for strength. Hardness correlates well with strength, which is how resistant the steel is to permanently deforming, and it usually correlates well with both yield stress and ultimate stress.
That matters at the edge. A thin edge that is too soft rolls over, because the stress exceeds what the steel can take without bending permanently. Rolling starts when stress exceeds the yield strength, and higher hardness usually means higher yield stress. Hardness helps a thin edge stay straight.
What hardness does not tell you
Toughness
Making steel harder generally makes it more brittle. A thin edge fails in two ways: it rolls, or it chips. Rolling is about strength. Chipping depends mainly on toughness (or brittleness). Because higher hardness leads to lower toughness, raising the hardness to stop rolling can make chipping more likely. There is no free fix, and the knife's geometry and use usually decide where the balance sits.
Wear resistance and edge retention
Wear resistance correlates with slicing edge retention, but hardness is not a stand-in for wear resistance. What matters more is the carbides in the steel. A few examples, measured in Vickers (Hv), which is a different scale from HRC, so don't compare them with a Rockwell reading: cementite is about 1000 Hv, chromium carbide about 1500 Hv and vanadium carbide about 2800 Hv. D2 has about 15% carbide, and A2 about a third as much. So two steels at the same HRC can wear very differently.
Whether the hardness is trustworthy
Hardness can also mislead about yield strength. Retained austenite is one cause: eliminating it increases the yield strength of steel even when the hardness is the same. Very low temperature tempering is another, where a higher hardness may not mean a higher yield stress. The number is a clue and not a verdict.
Everything else
Edge geometry is the other half of the story. Thinner, sharper, more acute edges are not as strong as heavier edges. Steel and heat treatment decide what a given geometry can survive, and the geometry decides what the steel is asked to survive. The steel's carbide structure matters too: small, evenly spread carbides support finer edges, while large or unevenly spread carbides give chips somewhere to start.
So what hardness should I aim for?
I don't think there is one good answer, and I would be suspicious of a guide that gave you one. Knives are often described as sitting somewhere from the high 50s to the low 60s HRC. That describes common practice and is not a target. I would not design a knife to a number I hadn't tied to a particular steel, a particular tempering temperature and the geometry I planned to grind.
Here is how I'd go about it:
- Start with your steel's own data. Tempering charts, such as the heat treatment experiments at Knife Steel Nerds, show the hardness each tempering temperature gave in that process. They often show how toughness changed too, which is the number you care about for a knife that will be hit or twisted.
- Keep the process together. Published experiments tie the starting condition, hold and quench to the results, so the property values belong to that process. Don't carry a hardness from one source's hold and quench over to a different process.
- Choose the tempering temperature for the balance you want. For the plain carbon steels most first knives are cut from, a higher tempering temperature generally gives a lower hardness. Some high-alloy steels behave differently, so read the chart for your steel and don't assume.
- Think about the geometry. A thin kitchen edge and a heavy chopping edge are asking different things of the same steel.
A routine for the bench
I would make a small test piece from the same bar, give it the same preparation and put it through the same heat treatment run as the knife. After tempering:
- Grind a flat, clean spot on the test piece, through any scale, and test it.
- Record the reading next to the steel, the batch, the hardening details and the tempering temperature.
- Compare it with what the source for your steel shows for that process.
- If the reading is far from what you expected, look at the whole record before changing one thing: the steel, the temperatures, the holds, the quench and the temper. A single reading can't tell you which of those went wrong.
Don't chase the highest number. It's more useful to repeat a process that works than to find one result that looks impressive. If you can't test hardness yourself, a heat treatment service or a local knifemaking club may be able to, and it is worth the small cost.
Reading a listing or a spec sheet
When a seller quotes a hardness, I'd ask:
- Which steel is it, and what was the tempering temperature?
- Was it measured on this knife or a test piece, or is it a target?
- Where was it measured, and on what kind of surface?
- Does the number come with anything about toughness or edge geometry?
If the answer to most of these is no, the number doesn't tell you much. That is Larrin's point about megapixels.
Where this comes from
Larrin Thomas's article on hardness at Knife Steel Nerds, his article on edge stability (which describes Roman Landes' idea of edge stability), and Wikipedia's article on the Rockwell scale for the test method, loads and test piece conditions. The arithmetic about dent depth and thickness is mine, from the formula in that article. If you test your own blades, tell us in a comment what you found.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…