What annealing is for
Annealing makes the steel soft and sets it up for the final heat treating steps. It has two jobs: to make the steel machinable, so it can be cut, drilled and ground, and to set the steel up for austenitising and quenching so it has a good heat treating response.
That is why bar sold for knifemaking is normally supplied annealed. The supplied condition is part of any route, so check it with your supplier. The steel pages on this site assume known annealed bar.
Two kinds of anneal
A subcritical anneal heats the steel below the temperature where austenite forms. "Subcritical" simply means a lower temperature than where austenite forms, which is the nonmagnetic phase.
A transformation anneal heats the steel into the austenite range and then cools it slowly. Done right, "a transformation called 'Divorced Eutectoid' (DET) can occur instead of pearlite formation", and "the carbon can diffuse into the existing carbides rather than forming new pearlite." Heat it too high and it goes the other way: "If the steel is heated to too high a temperature, then pearlite will form instead."
Do you need to do it?
Stock removal from bought annealed bar: no. Leave the bar alone until the hardening heat.
Forging: yes. "When steel is forged it is no longer in the annealed condition," and "The basic process that needs to be followed is a normalize and anneal." Stainless and high alloy tool steels are the exception, because "Stainless steels and high alloy tool steels cannot be normalized": for those, "you should simply anneal instead."
The cooling rates the sources give
A general datasheet rule of thumb: "Anneal by heating to the recommended temperature for 15-30 minutes, cool at 600°F/hr (300°C/hr) to 1100°F."
Stainless steel is different. Annealing temperatures are typically higher, with 1600-1650°F (870-900°C) being most typical. Datasheets often call for 25°F an hour, which takes over 24 hours, and a workable summary is to anneal at 1600-1650°F for two hours, then slow cool at 100°F/hr to 1000°F. Crucible's MagnaCut datasheet asks for 1650°F (900°C) held for 2 hours and a cool "no faster than 25°F (15°C) per hour to 1100°F (595°C)."
Those are different rates for the same job. I would not choose between them from a page. Follow the datasheet for your steel and keep the whole cycle together, the way you would any other route.
Protect it, and leave stock
For stainless steel annealed after forging, it is best to wrap the steel in foil during annealing, and to leave extra steel to grind away.
Where this comes from
- Introduction to Knife Steel Heat Treating from a Metallurgist, Knife Steel Nerds. The stages, equipment, datasheets and what to do when datasheets disagree. Larrin Thomas’s own recommendations; it gives no schedule for a particular steel.
- How Annealing of Steel Works: Subcritical vs Transformation Annealing, Knife Steel Nerds. What the two kinds of anneal do to the carbides. Mostly experiments on a few steels, not a bench recipe.
- How to Thermal Cycle Knife Steel, Knife Steel Nerds. Normalising, annealing and grain refinement for knife steels, with datasheet-style rules of thumb. It does not give a blanket rule for when a forged knife needs which step.
- How to Anneal Stainless Steel After Forging, Knife Steel Nerds. Annealing stainless knife steel after forging, with the datasheet rate and Larrin Thomas’s own. Tested on AEB-L and MagnaCut among others.
- CPM MagnaCut data sheet, issue 1, March 2021, Crucible Industries. The producer’s own composition, toughness, edge retention, annealing and heat treatment figures. Producer data, not independent testing.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…