What heat treating is trying to do
Bar steel is bought soft so it can be cut, drilled and ground. Heat treating makes it hard enough to hold an edge, then gives back enough toughness that the edge does not chip. The hardness comes from heating the steel until it changes structure and then cooling it fast enough that it changes again into something hard. Tempering is the step that takes some of that hardness back.
A great steel and heat treatment cannot save a bad design, and heat treatment can only do so much. That is the tone for everything here.
The stages, in order
Each stage has its own page. Not every route uses every one: bought annealed bar skips the first two, and most routes skip the cold step.
The stages
- Anneal
Bought bar is normally supplied annealed. Forged steel is not: When steel is forged it is no longer in the annealed condition.
- Normalise
For forged low alloy steel, normalise and then anneal. It "gives the steel a uniform microstructure and grain size." Stainless and high alloy tool steels cannot be normalised, so they are annealed.
- Austenitise
The hardening heat, "generally 1450-2250°F depending on the steel and desired hardness."
- Quench
Fast enough for the steel's hardenability: oil, aluminium plates or air.
- Cold treatment (optional)
"Think of cryo as an extension of the quench down to lower temperatures."
- Temper
"Typically steel is tempered at least twice, and each temper is usually 1-2 hours long."
The stage pages
- Annealing knife steel
What annealing is for, the two kinds, and the cooling rates the sources give.
- Normalising and thermal cycling
What normalising does, who needs it, and the grain refinement cycles worth skipping.
- Austenitising a knife: temperature and soak
The hardening heat: temperature, soak, preheat, datasheets and the magnet.
- Foil or coatings: protecting knife steel
Foil, coatings and decarburisation, and when the problem is small enough to grind off.
- Quenching knives: oils, plates and speed
Hardenability, quench media from water to plates, and the oil comparison and its limits.
- Tempering knife steel: temperature and cycles
Why and how many times to temper, temperature vs time, and the ranges to avoid.
- Cold treatment and cryo for knives
What cold treatment does, freezer vs dry ice vs liquid nitrogen, toughness and timing.
Which route are you on?
If you bought annealed bar, ground the blade and have a furnace, you start at the hardening heat. If you forge, you normalise and anneal first. If you cannot hold a temperature accurately, the advice, even after testing a careful forge method, is still to use a furnace or send the blade out to a professional heat treater for most people.
The ways to do it
- Heat treating knives in a forge
The dangers, the tested method, the steels that suit it and the ones that do not.
- Heat treating knives in an electric furnace
What a furnace fixes, uneven corners, tempering ovens and the stainless extras.
- Heat treating knives in a salt pot
What salt gives you, why it suits a narrow range of steels, and the water rule.
- Sending knives out to be heat treated
When to send it out, how factory and custom heat treating compare, and what to ask.
Choose a route from a datasheet, then keep it together
Start from the producer's datasheet: "The first thing you should look for is a 'recommended' heat treatment." Cross-check more than one, and know where each came from, because "Sometimes these datasheets are generated by steel suppliers and not by metallurgists working for the steel company."
Keep the hardening temperature, soak, quench, cold step and temper together from one source. Numbers from different sources are not interchangeable, and the highest temperature from one page and the lowest temper from another is not a route.
Worked routes, one per steel
Each route below is a complete schedule from one source, to be established on a coupon cut from your own stock. None of them promises a hardness, and each page says where its numbers come from and how far to trust them.
The thirteen worked routes
- Heat treating 1084
1084: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating 1095
1095: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating 80CrV2
80CrV2: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating 5160
5160: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating 52100
52100: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating O1
O1: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating AEB-L
AEB-L: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating CPM MagnaCut
CPM MagnaCut: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating 8670
8670: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating D2
D2: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating Nitro-V
Nitro-V: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating S35VN
S35VN: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
- Heat treating CPM-154
CPM-154: the equipment, the hardening hold, the quench and the temper, as one route.
Before the blade gets hot
Oil quenching needs a stable non-combustible tank, enough depth and volume, a fitted metal lid, ventilation and suitable fire protection. Oil burns: "Oils have a 'flash point' above which they will ignite." Keep water away from quench oil, and never use waste motor oil.
Molten salt and water do not mix, and cryogenic liquids need a suitable vessel, ventilation, face and hand protection, and training. Have the tempering oven ready, and rehearse the transfer with a cold blank.
What heat treating cannot fix
The shape of the edge matters more than most of the claims made for a heat treatment. Heat treatment is often called the most important factor for high performance knives, but it can only do so much. What a hardness number does and does not tell you is in the hardness guide, and what grind to put on the blade is in the grinds guide.
Elsewhere
- What the HRC number means
What a Rockwell reading measures and how to test a blade.
- Knife grinds explained
Flat, hollow, convex, saber, Scandi and S grinds in cross-section.
Where this comes from
- Introduction to Knife Steel Heat Treating from a Metallurgist, Knife Steel Nerds. The stages, equipment, datasheets and what to do when datasheets disagree. Larrin Thomas’s own recommendations; it gives no schedule for a particular steel.
- How to Use a Steel Datasheet to Develop a Heat Treatment, Knife Steel Nerds. Reading a producer datasheet: soak, temper and temperature choices. Larrin Thomas’s recommendations, not a standard.
- How to Heat Treat Knife Steel in a Forge, Knife Steel Nerds. A method for reducing forge error, tested on seven low alloy steels. The author still recommends a furnace or a professional for most people.
- 13 Myths about Heat Treating Knives, Knife Steel Nerds. Thirteen common claims and the author’s answers.
- How to Pick the Best Steel for Every Knife, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s method for choosing a steel, with his own recommendations. Opinion informed by his testing; the charts are images.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…