What the heat is doing
Heating the steel past its transformation temperature forms austenite, which can dissolve carbon and alloying elements. Quench it fast enough afterwards and the austenite becomes martensite, which is the hard structure you want. How much carbon is dissolved, and how large the grains are, depends on the temperature and the time.
The general range is 1450-2250°F, depending on the steel and desired hardness. That is a wide range because steels are very different: the routes on this site run from the mid 1400s up to 2050°F.
How long to hold it
Soak is the time held at temperature once the steel is at it. A 10 minute hold is often recommended for many low alloy steels, rather than the 5 minutes recommended by some, and you do not need to be afraid of the 15-30 minute soak times the datasheets recommend.
Thickness matters: "if the steel is thicker than 1/8″ (3.3 mm) it may need a few more minutes." And the mistake to avoid is the one people overlook: "Undersoaking is a more common issue than oversoaking."
Do you preheat?
Some datasheets call for a preheat, to help the steel heat evenly. Knives are thin enough that this is not typically an issue, and the usual advice is to hold the furnace for 30 minutes at the target final austenitising temperature instead. Some routes still use one: the AEB-L route here follows its supplier's sheet, which preheats at 1500°F for 15 minutes.
Choosing the temperature
Start from the producer's datasheet and look for the recommended heat treatment. If it gives a range, using the middle of the range is generally safe. Cross-check more than one, and understand why the datasheet recommends what it does.
Know where a datasheet came from. Sometimes these datasheets are generated by steel suppliers and not by metallurgists working for the steel company. Even experienced knifemakers can provide poor heat treating advice.
What a magnet can and cannot tell you
For simple low alloy steels, the point at which the steel becomes nonmagnetic is near the temperature at which it should be quenched. But it is not the Curie point: it is an indication that the steel has transformed to austenite, not the result of the Curie transition. The usual range is 1350 to 1380°F, which is lower than the hardening temperatures on this site.
It misleads on some steels. Chromium raises the transformation temperature, so such steels go nonmagnetic below their best austenitising temperature. And 52100 must be heated beyond nonmagnetic to a greater degree than many other low alloy steels. The conclusion is that a controlled furnace is better, because you can be much more sure about the consistency in your heat treatment.
Where this comes from
- Introduction to Knife Steel Heat Treating from a Metallurgist, Knife Steel Nerds. The stages, equipment, datasheets and what to do when datasheets disagree. Larrin Thomas’s own recommendations; it gives no schedule for a particular steel.
- Austenitizing Part 1: What It Is, Knife Steel Nerds. What austenitising does to the structure. Background, with no recommended schedule.
- How to Use a Steel Datasheet to Develop a Heat Treatment, Knife Steel Nerds. Reading a producer datasheet: soak, temper and temperature choices. Larrin Thomas’s recommendations, not a standard.
- Can You Trust Your Magnet During Heat Treating?, Knife Steel Nerds. What losing magnetism does and does not tell you about the steel.
- 13 Myths about Heat Treating Knives, Knife Steel Nerds. Thirteen common claims and the author’s answers.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…