What goes wrong
Heated in air, steel forms scale, and the surface loses carbon, which is called decarburisation. A decarburised surface is softer than the steel under it, which is why a hardness reading on an unground blade can mislead. The remedy is protection while hot, or enough stock to grind the damaged layer away, or both.
Foil
Stainless foil is the common answer for makers. The two common types are 309 and 321 foil, which are stainless steels. The 321 foil is rated up to 2000°F and the 309 up to 2240°F, so the temperature matters when you buy it.
In testing, the stainless AEB-L left unprotected had a very thick decarb layer measuring over 0.2 mm (~0.01 inches), and foil is strongly preferred for air hardening steels. The stainless routes on this site (AEB-L, MagnaCut) assume foil or an equivalent.
Coatings
Anti-scale coatings are painted or dipped on. In one comparison the coatings differed from one another in how much scale and decarburisation they allowed. Treat that test with care: it was small, it was a first time using many of the coatings, so there can certainly be criticism of the technique, and one coating maker said the result was not typical of its users.
There is also a quenching catch: quenching slowly with coatings applied carries a significant danger.
When it matters less
For the simple oil and water hardening steels, decarburisation is smaller than people fear. Testing found that the amount of decarb is relatively small at temperatures typical of water and oil hardening steels, meaning under about 1600°F (870°C).
Either way, leave stock. The routes here tell you to leave measurable cleanup stock on the faces and edge, and to grind through the surface layer before you test hardness.
Where this comes from
- Introduction to Knife Steel Heat Treating from a Metallurgist, Knife Steel Nerds. The stages, equipment, datasheets and what to do when datasheets disagree. Larrin Thomas’s own recommendations; it gives no schedule for a particular steel.
- Coatings vs Foil: Heat Treating Steel, Knife Steel Nerds. One small comparison of coatings and foil on a few steels. The author says his technique could be criticised, and one coating maker said the result was not typical of its users.
- How to Anneal Stainless Steel After Forging, Knife Steel Nerds. Annealing stainless knife steel after forging, with the datasheet rate and Larrin Thomas’s own. Tested on AEB-L and MagnaCut among others.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…