Where the risk is
Two dangers stand out: overheating for grain growth, and excessive carbon in solution. The biggest problem with forge heat treating is that the temperatures are not well controlled. Uneven heating, which leaves spots of different hardness or toughness, follows from that.
The method that was tested
Start from a normalised, pearlitic structure, not spheroidised annealed bar. Then watch the magnet: heat to nonmagnet and no hotter. Quench in a fast oil. The test samples were tempered twice for 2 hours at 400°F/205°C.
It is a method for reducing error, not for removing it. The conclusion is still to use a furnace or send the blade out to a professional heat treater for most people.
Which steels
The testing matches steels to jobs: 5160 and 8670 are best for knives requiring high toughness like heavy choppers; 1095, O1 and 52100 are best for fine cutting knives like kitchen knives, with 52100 the pick of the three; and 1084 and 80CrV2 are best for general purpose knives.
And the exclusion: "Basically any steel with 3% chromium or more." That rules out the stainless steels here. It also means the AEB-L and MagnaCut routes are furnace routes only.
What a supplier says
The New Jersey Steel Baron sheets note that "forge heat treating without PID temperature control limits accurate means of maintaining temperature," and cut the soak to its minimum for forge work. For O1 the sheet goes further: the soak is "a crucial factor and not recommended for forge heat treating without PID or similar calibrated equipment."
Where this comes from
- Introduction to Knife Steel Heat Treating from a Metallurgist, Knife Steel Nerds. The stages, equipment, datasheets and what to do when datasheets disagree. Larrin Thomas’s own recommendations; it gives no schedule for a particular steel.
- How to Heat Treat Knife Steel in a Forge, Knife Steel Nerds. A method for reducing forge error, tested on seven low alloy steels. The author still recommends a furnace or a professional for most people.
- How to Thermal Cycle Knife Steel, Knife Steel Nerds. Normalising, annealing and grain refinement for knife steels, with datasheet-style rules of thumb. It does not give a blanket rule for when a forged knife needs which step.
- Factory vs Custom Heat Treating of Knives, Knife Steel Nerds. Compares how knives are heat treated in factories and in small shops. The author says some of his own tests may favour custom work.
- O1 Heat Treat, July 2020, New Jersey Steel Baron. A supplier’s schedule for O1, not a producer’s. Larrin Thomas advises caution with this supplier’s datasheets, so it is a comparison here and not the route.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…