Why it is a good option
Even after testing the forge method, the recommendation is still furnace heat treating or sending out to a professional heat treater for most people. Bar and tools for a furnace route, especially a stainless one, cost real money, and the first few attempts on your own are experiments.
Factory and custom
Factory heat treating compares with small-shop heat treating mainly on the quench: the slower quench rate in many vacuum furnaces used by knife production facilities and large custom knifemakers can often lead to a reduction in hardness and toughness. So there is a potential for small batch heat treating to be superior.
The comparison is careful about its own limits: the gap found is not because the small-shop heat treating was superior but rather due to differences in the design of the blades, the edge geometry, and how the blades were sharpened.
What to ask a heat treater
"In many cases the knowledge of the person performing the heat treatment is more important than the equipment being used." Ask what steel they have treated and how, what quench they use for it, whether they temper at least twice, and how they check hardness. And be sceptical of big claims: "every buyer should be skeptical of knifemakers that are claiming their heat treatments are significantly better."
Hardness alone is not the test: "hitting the target hardness is only one tiny piece of the puzzle."
Tell them the supplied condition
Send the steel grade, the supplied condition, the thickness, how much stock you left on the edge, and any cold treatment you want. A route that works for a known annealed bar will not be right for a recycled piece of unknown steel.
Where this comes from
- Introduction to Knife Steel Heat Treating from a Metallurgist, Knife Steel Nerds. The stages, equipment, datasheets and what to do when datasheets disagree. Larrin Thomas’s own recommendations; it gives no schedule for a particular steel.
- How to Heat Treat Knife Steel in a Forge, Knife Steel Nerds. A method for reducing forge error, tested on seven low alloy steels. The author still recommends a furnace or a professional for most people.
- Factory vs Custom Heat Treating of Knives, Knife Steel Nerds. Compares how knives are heat treated in factories and in small shops. The author says some of his own tests may favour custom work.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…