Fast enough for this steel
Steels differ in how fast they have to be cooled to harden fully, and that is what hardenability measures. Hardenability is not a measure of how hard a steel can get. Instead it is a measure of how fast you have to quench to achieve maximum hardness for a given composition.
The chart shows what drives it: Mo is the most effective hardenability element. The estimates are not perfect but can give a general idea of relative hardenability, and that caution applies to the whole comparison.
The media
The speed of a quench falls into four classes: 1) water and brine, 2) fast oil, 3) medium oil, and 4) slow oil. Air hardening steels are different. They harden without a liquid quench, and makers cool them between aluminium plates, with compressed air on the AEB-L route here.
A low hardenability steel needs a fast medium. 52100 sits in the middle: "52100 has medium hardenability so it straddles the line between water/fast oil and medium oil." 80CrV2 is easier: "it will fully harden even with 1/4″ stock quenched in slow oil."
Which oil
Coupons of W2, 1095, 26C3, 1084, 80CrV2, 52100, O1, 15N20 and CruForgeV in Parks 50, Parks AAA, Quenchfast, Quenchall, Citgo Quenchol 521 and canola were hardened. The takeaways: canola is not a particularly great quenchant, and if you buy only one oil it should be a fast oil like Parks 50 so that you can quench the low hardenability steels.
The limits matter. The test measured hardness, not toughness (toughness came from a separate study of 8670), and it used one canola product. A test at 1/4 inch is a useful guide for thinner knives: if it fully hardens at that cross-section then thinner knives will also work with that particular oil.
Supplier sheets name different oils for different steels. The New Jersey Steel Baron sheet for O1, for instance, says "Parks 50 is not recommended," while testing of 52100 recommends a fast oil. They are different steels and different sources, which is why each route on this site names its own oil and keeps it with its schedule.
Plates
The stainless routes here quench between aluminium plates to 50°C (125°F) or below. Crucible's MagnaCut datasheet allows "plate quench, air or positive pressure quench (2 bar minimum) to below 125°F (50°C)." Plate contact is the thing to rehearse: the AEB-L route here warns against a folded seam in the foil packet between a blade face and a plate.
Fire
Oil burns. "Oils have a 'flash point' above which they will ignite." Use a stable non-combustible tank with enough depth and volume, a fitted metal lid, ventilation and suitable fire protection. Keep water away from quench oil. Never use waste motor oil.
Where this comes from
- Introduction to Knife Steel Heat Treating from a Metallurgist, Knife Steel Nerds. The stages, equipment, datasheets and what to do when datasheets disagree. Larrin Thomas’s own recommendations; it gives no schedule for a particular steel.
- Which Quenching Oil is Best for Knives?, Knife Steel Nerds. Hardness after quenching in several oils, on low alloy steels. Toughness was not tested in this article, and only one canola product was used.
- How Fast Do You Have to Quench? Hardenability of Steel, Knife Steel Nerds. What hardenability means and how steels compare. The relative figures are estimates, and the author says so.
- How to Heat Treat 52100, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s tests of 52100. The article says it makes no corrosion statements and does not claim to be the best possible treatment.
- How to Heat Treat 80CrV2, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s tests of 80CrV2, with datasheet comparisons. Test coupons were sealed in stainless foil.
- CPM MagnaCut data sheet, issue 1, March 2021, Crucible Industries. The producer’s own composition, toughness, edge retention, annealing and heat treatment figures. Producer data, not independent testing.
- O1 Heat Treat, July 2020, New Jersey Steel Baron. A supplier’s schedule for O1, not a producer’s. Larrin Thomas advises caution with this supplier’s datasheets, so it is a comparison here and not the route.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…