Learn / Heat treating

Cold treatment and cryo for knives

Cryo is the most argued-about step in knife heat treating. Some of the arguments are about whether it works. Most are about what it costs.

Knife Templates · 3 min read

What it is

Think of cryo as an extension of the quench down to lower temperatures. After a quench, some austenite is left over. Colder temperatures turn more of it into martensite. The answer to the claim that a freezer does nothing is that it is a matter of degree: cryo is not an on/off thing, and the colder you go the better for minimising retained austenite.

Freezer, dry ice, liquid nitrogen

Colder works better, and so does speed. In a freezer test, waiting only a few minutes led to no change in retained austenite, and across the steels tested, the colder the temperature the less a delay affected the cold treatment. Crucible says the same of a household freezer for MagnaCut: it "has no effect unless performed directly after the quench with no delay."

The supplier sheet for AEB-L prefers liquid nitrogen and says a dry ice and kerosene bath at about -100°F (-74°C) "will suffice." A household freezer does not match that bath, so a route that asks for one is not satisfied by the other.

What it costs in toughness

It is not free. The majority of studies have found a reduction in toughness with cryo, and a 52100 test showed a small decrease in toughness even after compensating for hardness. On edge retention, studies found no difference beyond what the extra hardness gives. It adds roughly half a Rockwell point to 52100, which is useful for applications requiring maximum strength.

Timing

Go straight from the quench. "A delay between the quench and the cold treatment can lead to less effect of the cold treatment." Hold time is short: "No real hold is necessary at the low temperature, the steel just needs to reach the temperature," and "Usually 60 minutes is fine for cryo or cold treatment."

Always temper afterwards. The AEB-L sheet says it plainly: "cryo treatment should always be followed by a tempering cycle." It also recommends clamping blades flat during the cold treatment, to avoid thermal shock warp.

Safety

Cryogenic liquids need a suitable vessel, ventilation, face and hand protection, and training. Never use a sealed container, and never improvise a flammable solvent bath beside a hot furnace.

Where this comes from

Next upHeat treating knives in a forgeThe dangers, the tested method, the steels that suit it and the ones that do not.

Comments

Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.

Loading comments…

Knife Templates