What tempering is for
The primary reason to temper the steel is to decrease its brittleness, or in other words, increase its toughness. The cost is hardness: tempering does not only increase toughness, it also usually decreases the hardness of the steel. Inside the steel, the carbon leaves the martensite by precipitating out as carbides.
How many times, how long
"Typically steel is tempered at least twice, and each temper is usually 1-2 hours long." The second temper has a reason: some of the austenite left over after the quench turns into fresh martensite on cooling, and "this newly formed martensite is brittle and should be tempered."
Between tempers, "Air cooling to room temperature in between is sufficient." A caution on retained austenite: "tempering is not guaranteed to transform all of the retained austenite."
Temperature beats time
"Therefore hardness is controlled more strongly by temperature because time is on a log scale." Doubling the time moves the hardness far less than a modest change in temperature does, so if a blade is off its target, change the temperature, not the clock.
Choosing the temperature
For many steels the datasheet is the place to start. "400°F is generally a good starting point for balanced properties," and "400°F is good for most steels, though some high alloy and high speed steels will recommend the 1000°F temper." Better still, "The best case scenario is to use toughness data to select a tempering temperature rather than hardness."
There are ranges to avoid, and they differ by steel. Tempering between about 450-750°F can lead to tempered martensite embrittlement. Tests on 5160 found a narrow best window: tempering above 400 or below 375°F is not recommended. For 80CrV2, tempering above 450°F is not recommended, and 300°F is attractive for thin knives with high cutting performance.
Stainless steels add a corrosion limit. Crucible says tempering MagnaCut "above 750°F (400°C) results in a decrease in corrosion resistance," and the supplier sheet for AEB-L warns against 800°F and above.
Tempering in a kitchen oven
A conventional oven is acceptable, "though the temperature will be more variable." The New Jersey Steel Baron sheets suggest a blade rack made from kiln furniture, or a roasting tray lined with fine sand, to hold heat and cut the swings. Check the oven against a good thermometer, not its dial.
Then test it
Hardness after tempering is the check, and a file is not one. The same sheets say "hardness calibrated files and chisels are relative testing methods and inaccurate for true hardness value reading." What a reading does and does not tell you has its own guide.
Where this comes from
- Introduction to Knife Steel Heat Treating from a Metallurgist, Knife Steel Nerds. The stages, equipment, datasheets and what to do when datasheets disagree. Larrin Thomas’s own recommendations; it gives no schedule for a particular steel.
- What Happens During Tempering of Steel?, Knife Steel Nerds. What changes in the steel during tempering. Background; it gives no recommended schedule for any steel.
- How to Use a Steel Datasheet to Develop a Heat Treatment, Knife Steel Nerds. Reading a producer datasheet: soak, temper and temperature choices. Larrin Thomas’s recommendations, not a standard.
- How to Heat Treat 5160: Optimizing Toughness, Knife Steel Nerds. Charpy tests of 5160 across austenitising and tempering temperatures, including a liquid nitrogen step. Its optimum belongs to that process.
- How to Heat Treat 80CrV2, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s tests of 80CrV2, with datasheet comparisons. Test coupons were sealed in stainless foil.
- CPM MagnaCut data sheet, issue 1, March 2021, Crucible Industries. The producer’s own composition, toughness, edge retention, annealing and heat treatment figures. Producer data, not independent testing.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…