How each is measured
Toughness here is measured with a Charpy test, a subsize, unnotched one with 2.5 x 10 x 55 mm specimens. Edge retention is measured with CATRA, which measures abrasive wear of knives. Those are specific tests, and a figure from one is not a figure from another.
Hardness is a third thing, and the HRC number does not tell you either of the others on its own. That has its own guide.
The trade-offs
"Usually more of one means less of the other." On carbide, "In general, more carbide means lower toughness but higher edge retention." And "There is no such thing as a steel that is a '10' in both toughness and edge retention."
Corrosion resistance has its own trade: "there is a trend where more corrosion resistant steels typically have a lower maximum hardness."
Choosing
"Instead, selecting a steel is about prioritizing the categories." For one job, "For hard use knives it is better to use a high toughness steel like 8670, Z-Tuff, and AEB-L." Which categories matter depends on the knife. A kitchen knife that is washed and dried asks different things of the steel from a chopper that is dropped in mud.
What steel cannot do
A great steel and heat treatment can't save a bad design, and the heat treatment can only do so much. The shape of the edge and how the knife is sharpened account for a lot of what people credit to the steel.
On ratings
Ratings articles are common, and the advice from the metallurgy sources is to ignore them; even the ratings published with the testing carry a reservation that they may change with new information. I treat them as one metallurgist's judgement, so this site does not rank steels.
Where this comes from
- How to Pick the Best Steel for Every Knife, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s method for choosing a steel, with his own recommendations. Opinion informed by his testing; the charts are images.
- Knife Steels Rated by a Metallurgist: Toughness, Edge Retention, and Corrosion Resistance, Knife Steel Nerds. One metallurgist’s ratings, which he says he may change. The rating tables are images, so this site quotes only the text.
- 13 Myths about Heat Treating Knives, Knife Steel Nerds. Thirteen common claims and the author’s answers.
- Carbide Types in Knife Steels, Knife Steel Nerds. What carbides are and how their amount, size and hardness trade toughness against wear resistance.
- Corrosion Resistance vs Hardness in Knife Steels, Knife Steel Nerds. How hardness, tempering and chromium relate to corrosion resistance.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…