Start with the knife
Selecting a steel is about prioritising the categories: toughness, edge retention and corrosion resistance. Usually more of one means less of the other. A kitchen knife that is washed and dried asks different things of the steel from a chopper that gets dropped in mud.
And keep the steel in proportion: "a great steel and heat treatment can't save a bad design."
Then your workshop
The first page under Choosing between steels is a picker. It narrows the steels by the equipment you have, whether you need stainless and what your knife is for, using only what the sources say.
A steel that suits the knife is no use if you cannot treat it. If you cannot hold a temperature accurately, the fallback for torch and uncontrolled forge heat treating is 1075/1084. With a controlled furnace and a fast oil, the low alloy steels here (1095, 80CrV2, 5160, 52100, 8670 and O1) are all open to you.
D2 and the stainless steels ask for far more: furnaces holding anywhere from about 1850°F up to 2050°F, quench plates and, in most of these routes, a cold treatment. They also rule out the forge, because "Basically any steel with 3% chromium or more" is unsuitable for the tested forge method.
Choosing between steels
- Which steel should your knife be?
Narrow the steels by your equipment, stainless or not, and your knife.
- 1084 or 1095?
Two plain carbon steels: the equipment each asks for and the toughness each showed in testing.
- 5160 or 80CrV2?
Two low alloy working-knife steels: toughness, tempering limits and edge life, from separate tests.
- AEB-L or MagnaCut?
Two stainless steels: composition, the properties each source reports, and what the routes ask of you.
- 1075, 1080, 15N20, 26C3 and W2
Five simple carbon steels, what the sources say about each, and where they disagree.
The thirteen steels, side by side
This is what each worked route asks of the maker. It is not a ranking, and the figures in the routes are examples to establish on a coupon, not promises.
| Steel | Kind | Stainless | Quench | Protection | Cold step |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1084 | Plain carbon | No | Fast oil (Parks 50) | Anti-scale protection | None in this route |
| 1095 | Plain carbon | No | Fast oil (Parks 50) | Anti-scale coating | None in this route |
| 80CrV2 | Low alloy | No | Oil, fast or medium | Surface protection | None in this route |
| 5160 | Low alloy spring steel | No | Medium-speed oil (Parks AAA) | Anti-scale protection | None in this route |
| 52100 | Low alloy bearing steel | No | Fast oil (Parks 50) | Surface protection | None in this route |
| O1 | Oil-hardening tool steel | No | Oil, no brand named | Surface protection | None in this route |
| AEB-L | Stainless | Yes | Aluminium plates and compressed air | Foil packet | Sub-zero treatment |
| CPM MagnaCut | Stainless, powder metallurgy | Yes | Quench plates | Foil or atmosphere protection | None in this route |
| 8670 | Low alloy, high toughness | No | Fast or medium oil (Parks AAA or Parks 50) | Surface protection | None in this route |
| D2 | High-chromium tool steel | No | Plate quench | Stainless wrap or other protection | Liquid nitrogen or dry ice |
| Nitro-V | Stainless | Yes | Plate quench | Not covered by the source | Liquid nitrogen, or a freezer straight after the quench |
| S35VN | Stainless, powder metallurgy | Yes | Plate quench | Not covered by the source | Liquid nitrogen, at least 30 minutes |
| CPM-154 | Stainless, powder metallurgy | Yes | Plate quench between aluminium plates | Stainless foil | Liquid nitrogen |
A page for each steel
- Knife steel: 1084
A plain carbon steel, the usual fallback when the heat is hard to control.
- Knife steel: 1095
A simple high-carbon steel with lower toughness than its reputation suggests.
- Knife steel: 80CrV2
A low alloy steel with good toughness and hardenability, but low wear resistance.
- Knife steel: 5160
A low alloy spring steel known for toughness, with a narrow tempering window.
- Knife steel: 52100
A non-stainless bearing steel with good toughness and a fine edge.
- Knife steel: O1
An oil-hardening tool steel that needs a long, controlled soak.
- Knife steel: AEB-L
A tough, fine-grained stainless steel whose route needs foil, plates and a cold step.
- Knife steel: CPM MagnaCut
A powder metallurgy stainless steel with the producer's own figures, and the caveats on them.
- Knife steel: 8670
A tough nickel-chromium low alloy steel with an easy heat treatment and low wear resistance.
- Knife steel: D2
A high-carbon, high-chromium tool steel that is not stainless and wants a cold step.
- Knife steel: Nitro-V
A nitrogen-alloyed relative of AEB-L with very good toughness and some untested claims.
- Knife steel: S35VN
A balanced powder metallurgy stainless steel, tougher and easier to grind than S30V.
- Knife steel: CPM-154
A well-rounded powder metallurgy stainless steel, easy to finish, with a toughness result that is still unexplained.
The ideas behind the choice
These pages explain what the properties are, how they are measured, why they trade against each other, and what the steel families are.
How steel works
- What is in knife steel
Carbides, chromium and stainless, and the trade-offs between toughness and wear.
- Toughness, edge retention and corrosion resistance
What the three properties are, how they are measured, and why they trade.
- Carbon, stainless, tool and powder metallurgy steels
The steel families and what each asks of the maker.
- Identifying stock steel
Spark test patterns, and why unidentified stock stays an experiment.
What I am leaving out
There are far more than thirteen knife steels. I have added the ones I can source properly, and I would rather have thirteen pages I stand behind than forty I do not. I also do not rank steels: the advice from the metallurgy sources is to ignore rating articles, and even published ratings carry a reservation that they may change with new information. I treat them as one metallurgist's judgement.
Then heat treat it
- How to heat treat a knife
The stages in order, the ways to do them, and a worked route for each steel.
Where this comes from
- How to Pick the Best Steel for Every Knife, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s method for choosing a steel, with his own recommendations. Opinion informed by his testing; the charts are images.
- Knife Steels Rated by a Metallurgist: Toughness, Edge Retention, and Corrosion Resistance, Knife Steel Nerds. One metallurgist’s ratings, which he says he may change. The rating tables are images, so this site quotes only the text.
- How to Heat Treat Knife Steel in a Forge, Knife Steel Nerds. A method for reducing forge error, tested on seven low alloy steels. The author still recommends a furnace or a professional for most people.
- CPM MagnaCut data sheet, issue 1, March 2021, Crucible Industries. The producer’s own composition, toughness, edge retention, annealing and heat treatment figures. Producer data, not independent testing.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…