Learn / Steel

Carbon, stainless, tool and powder metallurgy steels

Knife steels fall into a few families, and the family tells you more about what the shop has to do than the grade does.

Knife Templates · 2 min read

Carbon and low alloy

The steels on this site that are not stainless (1084, 1095, 80CrV2, 5160, 52100) are carbon or low alloy. They rust, they harden in oil at modest temperatures, and for forging, "Low alloy steels are significantly easier to forge for a variety of reasons." Their routes run from about 1475 to 1525°F.

Tool steels

O1 is a tool steel, the family that gave knifemakers "the first 'oil hardening' steel developed in 1905." It is non-stainless, and its producers' sheets call for a modest hardening heat, 780 to 850°C, and an oil quench.

Stainless

AEB-L and MagnaCut are stainless. Their routes need far higher temperatures (1066°C and 1121°C), foil or an atmosphere to protect the surface, plates for the quench, and for AEB-L a cold treatment. They also rule out the forge: "Basically any steel with 3% chromium or more" is unsuitable for the tested forge method.

Powder metallurgy

"Powder metallurgy is a method by which very tiny ingots are formed." "Each particle of the powder is like its own tiny ingot," and "Therefore the cooling rates are much faster than conventional casting."

What it changes is the carbides. The result is "a much finer and more uniform carbide structure than in a conventionally cast steel," where "440C, D2, and 154CM with conventional casting and processing still have carbides that are greater than 10 microns." The process also let designers use more of some elements: "the powder metallurgy process would allow them to develop steels with higher vanadium contents." MagnaCut is a powder metallurgy steel.

Where this comes from

Next upIdentifying stock steelSpark test patterns, and why unidentified stock stays an experiment.

Comments

Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.

Loading comments…

Knife Templates