Carbides
Carbides are hard and brittle, similar to a ceramic material. They are what make a steel wear-resistant and also what makes it less tough: higher carbon means more carbide, and the more carbide a steel has, and the larger the carbides, the lower the toughness. The reason is that carbides act as crack initiation sites.
The other side of the same fact: "The higher the hardness of the carbide, the stronger the contribution to wear resistance and edge retention." That is why steel designers chase small, hard carbides: "using a smaller amount of harder carbides can provide a better combination of toughness and edge retention."
Chromium and stainless
Chromium is what makes steel stainless. "The chromium forms an oxide layer at the surface of the steel that prevents rust from forming." There is no universal threshold: "Sometimes the cutoff for a steel being 'stainless' is given as 10.5, 11, or 12% chromium," and "There isn't any real agreement as far as I can tell."
Chromium only helps if it is free. "D2 steel with ~12% chromium is not stainless because the high carbon content means that many chromium carbides are formed," which ties the chromium up. Chromium carbides also cost you twice: "The chromium carbides are softer which leads to less wear resistance, but larger which reduces toughness."
Designing around it
MagnaCut is built around exactly this problem. Crucible describes a design "which eliminates chromium carbide in the heat treated microstructure," leaving only vanadium and niobium carbides, which it says also improves corrosion resistance.
Hardness and corrosion
Heat treatment can undo a stainless steel's rust resistance. "Tempering in the high temperature range (>750°F), also relatively common, significantly reduces corrosion resistance," and "hardness does not correlate with corrosion resistance for a given steel," though "there is a trend where more corrosion resistant steels typically have a lower maximum hardness."
What this page leaves out
There are other elements in knife steels, and I have not found a source I would stand behind for what each does, so this page does not guess. It covers what I can source.
Where this comes from
- Carbide Types in Knife Steels, Knife Steel Nerds. What carbides are and how their amount, size and hardness trade toughness against wear resistance.
- What is the Future of Stainless Knife Steel Design?, Knife Steel Nerds. Why chromium makes steel stainless and why chromium carbides get in the way.
- Corrosion Resistance vs Hardness in Knife Steels, Knife Steel Nerds. How hardness, tempering and chromium relate to corrosion resistance.
- CPM MagnaCut data sheet, issue 1, March 2021, Crucible Industries. The producer’s own composition, toughness, edge retention, annealing and heat treatment figures. Producer data, not independent testing.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…