What differs
The names tell you most of it. In the SAE numbering the last two digits are the carbon in hundredths of a percent, so 1084 is about 0.84% carbon, and 1095 is a simple carbon steel with 0.95% carbon and small amounts of Mn and Si. Neither is stainless, and both rust if left wet.
On toughness the testing finds a gap. 1095 and O1 both showed relatively low toughness in earlier tests, likely because of plate martensite, while steels that avoid plate martensite, like 52100, 1084 and 80CrV2, are a cheaper and simpler way around it. That is a result from the tests, not a promise about your bar.
For the quench, the oil testing makes the general point: if you buy only one oil, make it a fast oil like Parks 50, so that you can quench the low hardenability steels. Both routes on this site name Parks 50.
| 1084 | 1095 | |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon | About 0.84%, from the name | 0.95% |
| Stainless | No | No |
| Toughness in the testing | Listed with the steels that avoid plate martensite | Relatively low, likely because of plate martensite |
| Its job in a forge | General purpose knives | Fine cutting knives like kitchen knives |
| Fallback for uncontrolled heat | 1075/1084 | Not named |
| Quench in the route here | Fast oil (Parks 50) | Fast oil (Parks 50) |
Where I would land
For a first carbon-steel build I would reach for 1084, because it asks the least of your equipment and is the steel the forge testing falls back on when the heat is hard to control. For a thin kitchen knife, if you have a furnace, I would look at 52100 before either, since the forge testing picks it of the three it lists for fine cutting. 1095 is still a fine steel in good hands, with a smaller margin for error than the name suggests.
Where this comes from
- How to Pick the Best Steel for Every Knife, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s method for choosing a steel, with his own recommendations. Opinion informed by his testing; the charts are images.
- How to Heat Treat Knife Steel in a Forge, Knife Steel Nerds. A method for reducing forge error, tested on seven low alloy steels. The author still recommends a furnace or a professional for most people.
- Bainite Heat Treatments of 52100, O1, and 1095: How Much Toughness?, Knife Steel Nerds. Austempering experiments and what they say about plate martensite in 1095 and O1. A different route from quench and temper.
- Which Quenching Oil is Best for Knives?, Knife Steel Nerds. Hardness after quenching in several oils, on low alloy steels. Toughness was not tested in this article, and only one canola product was used.
- 1084 Heat Treat, July 2020, New Jersey Steel Baron. Supplier schedule for controlled equipment. Fahrenheit is authoritative where the PDF prints an inconsistent Celsius conversion. Example setpoints below sit inside its ranges; no hardness is guaranteed.
- 1095 Heat Treat, July 2020, New Jersey Steel Baron. Supplier schedule for controlled equipment. Fahrenheit is authoritative where the PDF prints an inconsistent Celsius conversion. Example setpoints below sit inside its ranges; no hardness is guaranteed.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…