How to use it
Choose the equipment you have and the list shows every steel whose route asks for that much or less. Then say whether you need stainless, and what your knife is for. Without JavaScript the whole list shows, and every row links to its steel.
13 steels
| Steel | Kind | Stainless | Quench | Cold step | What the sources say it suits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1084 | Plain carbon | No | Fast oil (Parks 50) | None in this route | General purpose knives, and the steel the forge testing falls back on when the heat is hard to control |
| 1095 | Plain carbon | No | Fast oil (Parks 50) | None in this route | Fine cutting knives like kitchen knives, though the testing would choose 52100 over it |
| 80CrV2 | Low alloy | No | Oil, fast or medium | None in this route | General purpose knives, with very low edge retention in CATRA testing |
| 5160 | Low alloy spring steel | No | Medium-speed oil (Parks AAA) | None in this route | Large knives that need very high toughness |
| 52100 | Low alloy bearing steel | No | Fast oil (Parks 50) | None in this route | Fine cutting knives, and good for general purpose knives |
| O1 | Oil-hardening tool steel | No | Oil, no brand named | None in this route | Fine cutting knives, though the testing recommends 52100 over it |
| AEB-L | Stainless | Yes | Aluminium plates and compressed air | Sub-zero treatment | Hard use knives, among the high toughness steels |
| CPM MagnaCut | Stainless, powder metallurgy | Yes | Quench plates | None in this route | Everything from thin slicers and kitchen knives to large chopping knives |
| 8670 | Low alloy, high toughness | No | Fast or medium oil (Parks AAA or Parks 50) | None in this route | Heavy choppers and other knives that need high toughness |
| D2 | High-chromium tool steel | No | Plate quench | Liquid nitrogen or dry ice | No job named; the testing found similar toughness and edge retention to 154CM, which is stainless |
| Nitro-V | Stainless | Yes | Plate quench | Liquid nitrogen, or a freezer straight after the quench | Described as well suited to knives requiring good toughness, with edge retention untested |
| S35VN | Stainless, powder metallurgy | Yes | Plate quench | Liquid nitrogen, at least 30 minutes | Well balanced: it does not particularly excel in any one category |
| CPM-154 | Stainless, powder metallurgy | Yes | Plate quench between aluminium plates | Liquid nitrogen | Described as having good all-around properties and being easy to finish |
No steel here fits all three. Loosen one of the filters.
What the equipment settings mean
A forge covers the steels named in the tested forge method, and even there the advice is to prefer furnace heat treating or sending the blade out to a professional heat treater for most people. O1 is in that list too, but its producers' sheets ask for a set soak, so I count it as a furnace steel. The other settings are the equipment each route on this site calls for, taken from the same chart as the Steel page.
What the knife setting means
A steel appears under a kind of knife only where a source I cite names that job for it, and each row says which. A steel with no job listed is one the sources I use do not match to a job. That is not a mark against it.
Where this comes from
- How to Heat Treat Knife Steel in a Forge, Knife Steel Nerds. A method for reducing forge error, tested on seven low alloy steels. The author still recommends a furnace or a professional for most people.
- How to Pick the Best Steel for Every Knife, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s method for choosing a steel, with his own recommendations. Opinion informed by his testing; the charts are images.
- Knife Steels Rated by a Metallurgist: Toughness, Edge Retention, and Corrosion Resistance, Knife Steel Nerds. One metallurgist’s ratings, which he says he may change. The rating tables are images, so this site quotes only the text.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…