Learn / Steel

Identifying stock steel

A file, a spring or an old tool could be almost anything. A spark test narrows the possibilities, but it cannot tell you which steel it is.

Knife Templates · 2 min read

What a spark test is

You touch the steel to a grinding wheel and read the sparks. Tharwa Valley Forge describes the patterns for several steels, and is clear about the limit: given the huge variety of steel, there are no guarantees.

Spark patterns, as Tharwa Valley Forge describes them
SteelSparks
Mild steelWhite, with tiny forks and varied lengths.
Medium-carbon steelMore forking than mild steel, with a wide range of lengths.
High-carbon steelA bushy pattern of forking that starts at the wheel, less bright than medium-carbon.
300-series stainlessNo forking, orange to straw.
Cast ironVery short sparks that begin at the wheel.
TitaniumA brilliant, blinding white, though it is not a ferrous metal.

Why it cannot name a steel

A pattern places a piece in a family (mild, medium carbon, high carbon, stainless). It does not tell you which alloy in the family, or what treatment it has had. An old spring may also have cracks from its service life. If you cannot identify a recycled spring, treat it as experimental material rather than stamping 5160 on the finished knife.

A quench test

Tharwa Valley Forge also suggests trying to harden a sample: "You can also try quenching in various ways to see if the sample can be hardened." That tells you whether the piece is useful, not what it is.

What I would do

Buy known bar with a grade, a supplied condition and a published schedule for a first knife. Keep experimental stock separate, label it as experimental, and make test knives from it that you do not sell as a named steel.

Where this comes from

  • Recycled steel identification, Tharwa Valley Forge. Spark test descriptions for common steels. The page itself says there can be no guarantees given the variety of steel.
Next upKnife steel: 1084A plain carbon steel, the usual fallback when the heat is hard to control.

Comments

Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.

Loading comments…

Knife Templates