What each one is
AEB-L is a martensitic stainless steel. Uddeholm's sheet for the strip steel gives about 0.65% carbon and 12.8% chromium and says "Hardened and tempered UHB Stainless AEB-L is resistant to corrosion in water and humid air." MagnaCut is a powder metallurgy steel, and Crucible says its design "eliminates chromium carbide in the heat treated microstructure."
On edge retention, AEB-L is similar to 52100, which is significantly lower than higher carbide content stainless steels. Crucible's CATRA figure for MagnaCut is 135 against 440C at 100, at 62.5 HRC. Those are different tests by different people, so I only set them side by side.
| AEB-L | MagnaCut | |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon | 0.65% (Uddeholm strip sheet) | 1.15% (Crucible) |
| Chromium | 12.8% (Uddeholm strip sheet) | 10.7% (Crucible) |
| Toughness | With 14C28N, the best in the high toughness group (independent testing) | Crucible: 38 ft-lbs at 62.5 HRC |
| Edge retention | Similar to 52100 (independent testing) | Crucible: 135 against 440C at 100 |
| Corrosion | Resistant in water and humid air (Uddeholm) | No visible corrosion after 72 hours in a 1% saltwater test (independent testing) |
| Temper ceiling | Not above about 750°F (400°C), says the producer's sheet | Above 750°F (400°C) reduces corrosion resistance, says Crucible |
| Quench in the route here | Aluminium plates and compressed air | Quench plates |
| Protection in the route here | Foil packet | Foil or atmosphere protection |
| Cold step in the route here | Sub-zero treatment | None in this route |
What you have to do
Neither is a forge steel: basically any steel with 3% chromium or more is unsuitable for the tested forge method. Both routes here want foil or an atmosphere and plates for the quench. The AEB-L route on this site adds a cold treatment and the MagnaCut route does not, and a household freezer does not stand in for the bath the AEB-L route asks for. Both lose corrosion resistance if tempered too hot.
Know which AEB-L you have. In the cold treatment tests, steel sold as AEB-L was Buderus X65Cr13 and needed about 50°F higher austenitising temperatures. Ask the supplier before you trust a hardening temperature.
Where this comes from
- Knife Steels Rated by a Metallurgist: Toughness, Edge Retention, and Corrosion Resistance, Knife Steel Nerds. One metallurgist’s ratings, which he says he may change. The rating tables are images, so this site quotes only the text.
- CPM MagnaCut data sheet, issue 1, March 2021, Crucible Industries. The producer’s own composition, toughness, edge retention, annealing and heat treatment figures. Producer data, not independent testing.
- CPM MagnaCut: The Next Breakthrough in Knife Steel, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s account of MagnaCut. He developed the steel, which the article acknowledges.
- UHB Stainless AEB-L data sheet (undated scan), Uddeholm. The producer’s own sheet for the strip steel, as a scan hosted by Knife Steel Nerds. It is undated, I found no current producer sheet, and it gives hold times only as a graph. Producer data, and a different route from the supplier’s.
- Dry Ice vs Liquid Nitrogen vs Freezer: How Cold Do You Need for Cryo?, Knife Steel Nerds. Freezer, dry ice and liquid nitrogen compared, on a few steels. The author notes the steel sold to him as AEB-L was not Uddeholm AEB-L.
- AEB-L Heat Treat, July 2020, New Jersey Steel Baron. Supplier schedule for controlled equipment. Fahrenheit is authoritative where the PDF prints an inconsistent Celsius conversion. Example setpoints below sit inside its ranges; no hardness is guaranteed.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…