What I could and could not find
For 15N20 and 26C3 there is a metallurgist's testing: both were heat treated and tested. For W2 there is an oil test that includes it, and nothing else of that kind. For 1075 and 1080 I found no producer sheet and no testing at all, only suppliers' recipes. I looked for producer heat treatment datasheets for all five and found none.
The one endorsement for 1075 I can quote is in a different context: for torch and uncontrolled forge heat treating, the advice is to echo others in recommending 1075/1084.
15N20
It can be grouped in with 8670 and L6 as nickel knife steels and is listed at 0.75% carbon. The tested route is to austenitise at 1475°F for 10 minutes and quench in room temperature Parks 50 oil, with two tempers of an hour each. A 300°F temper left it at about 63.5 Rc, but the toughness was about 9 ft-lbs, and tempering at 350°F instead gave a huge increase in toughness. The summary is that 350 to 400°F gives the optimal balance of high hardness and toughness.
26C3
It is listed at 1.25% carbon. 26C3 is not a true oil hardening steel, so it needs a fast oil to fully harden, similar to a steel like 1095. The recommended heat treatment is 1475°F for 10 minutes followed by a fast oil quench, and the recommended tempering range is 300 to 350°F, though both higher and lower is possible for certain knives. Tempering above 450°F (tempered martensite embrittlement) or below 200°F (not tested) is not recommended.
W2
W2 turns up in the oil testing, grouped with 1095 and 26C3 as water hardening steels. The surprise was how they behaved in the fastest oil: these water hardening grades did not fully harden in the Parks 50, and they were more sensitive to cross-section and oil than expected. I found no producer sheet for W2, so I give no route.
Where the sources disagree
The quench is where it falls apart. The Nordic Edge recipe for simple carbon steels, 1075 and 15N20 among them, says to quench in lukewarm canola and not to use water. Testing of canola found it is not a particularly great quenchant, with the advice to buy a commercial quenching oil instead, and for 15N20 specifically canola clearly led to softer steel.
Pop's Knife Supply lists W-2 and 26C3 with a Parks 50 quench. The oil tests, mostly on quarter-inch stock, found W2, 1095 and 26C3 did not fully harden in the Parks 50, and the advice for steels in the water hardening category is to use water if the steel is thicker than 1/8″. The separate 26C3 article, on the other hand, recommends fast oil. Both are the same metallurgist's work, and the oil tests show how sensitive these grades are to section, so the thickness behind each result matters. Test at your own.
The holds disagree too: "No hold time required" in the Nordic Edge recipe, 5 to 15 minutes in Pop's table, and 10 minutes in the tests.
| Source | Steel | Austenitise | Hold | Quench | Temper |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Independent testing | 15N20 | 1475°F | 10 minutes | Room temperature Parks 50 | Twice, 1 hour each, 350 to 400°F |
| Independent testing | 26C3 | 1475°F | 10 minutes | Fast oil | 300 to 350°F |
| Nordic Edge, a supplier | 1075 and 15N20 among others | 815°C (1500°F), non-magnetic | None required | Lukewarm canola | 2 hours twice at 200°C (390°F) |
| Pop's Knife Supply, a supplier | 1084, 1080 and 1075 | 1450 to 1480°F | 5 to 15 minutes | Parks 50 | Twice for 2 hours, 350 to 500°F |
| Pop's Knife Supply, a supplier | 15N20 | 1450 to 1480°F | 5 to 15 minutes | Oil | Twice for 2 hours, 400 to 500°F |
| Pop's Knife Supply, a supplier | W-2 | 1450 to 1475°F | 5 to 15 minutes | Parks 50 | Twice for 2 hours, 350 to 500°F |
| Pop's Knife Supply, a supplier | 26C3 | 1472 to 1508°F | 10 minutes | Parks 50 | 2 hours, 300 to 350°F |
What I would do
Treat anything here as a coupon to run before the knife, at the thickness of the knife. I have no source I can stand behind for 1075 or 1080, so I give no route for them. If you want a plain carbon steel with the sourcing behind it, 1084 and 80CrV2 have a page and a route here.
The steels with a route
- Knife steel: 1084
A plain carbon steel, the usual fallback when the heat is hard to control.
- Knife steel: 80CrV2
A low alloy steel with good toughness and hardenability, but low wear resistance.
Where this comes from
- How to Heat Treat Nickel Knife Steels: 15N20, 8670, L6, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s tests of 15N20 (austenitised at 1475°F, quenched in room temperature Parks 50, tempered twice for an hour at 300 to 450°F). Hardness and toughness charts are images; this site quotes only the text.
- How to Heat Treat 26C3 Steel, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s tests of 26C3 samples from Alpha Knife Supply. He cites the producer’s brochure for the steel but I found no producer heat treatment datasheet for it.
- Which Quenching Oil is Best for Knives?, Knife Steel Nerds. Hardness after quenching in several oils, on low alloy steels. Toughness was not tested in this article, and only one canola product was used.
- How to Heat Treat Knife Steel in a Forge, Knife Steel Nerds. A method for reducing forge error, tested on seven low alloy steels. The author still recommends a furnace or a professional for most people.
- How to heat treat carbon steel (1084, 1075, 15N20, 5160 and other simple carbon steels), Nordic Edge. An Australian knifemaking supplier’s blog post for makers with a forge or an uncontrolled heat. A supplier’s advice, not tested data, and its canola quench disagrees with Larrin Thomas’s oil tests.
- Heat treating and tempering information, Pop’s Knife Supply. A supplier’s table of austenitising range, hold, quench and tempering by steel. A supplier’s figures, not tested data, and it says nothing of the stock thickness behind them.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…