Where I would start
An oil-hardening, non-stainless tool steel. It can make useful knives, but being sold as ground flat stock does not mean it arrives ready to hold a cutting edge. Uddeholm, BÖHLER, Industeel and Carpenter each sell it under their own name and each sheet gives the standard grade: AISI O1, W.-Nr 1.2510.
Uddeholm’s schedule for its Arne steel in a controlled furnace. It is written for tools, not knives, and its tempering is a graph, so you choose the temper from the graph and prove it on a coupon.
Get the equipment ready
A controlled furnace with surface protection (the sheet says to “protect the part against decarburization and oxidation during hardening”), quench oil, and a checked tempering oven.
Measure the furnace and tempering oven independently where possible. A controller display is a setpoint, not proof that the whole blade has reached it. Timing a hold starts after equalisation, not as soon as the door closes.
A process to work from
Use this as a complete route to establish on a coupon from your stock. Temperatures in Celsius are rounded conversions of the Fahrenheit setpoints. A different supplier, section or starting condition can need a different process.
| Stage | What to do |
|---|---|
| Prepare | Finish the profile, holes and burr removal while soft. Leave measurable cleanup stock on the faces and edge. |
| Preheat | 600 to 700°C (1110 to 1290°F). Carpenter’s sheet says the opposite: “Without preheating, place the tool right in the hot furnace.” |
| Austenitise | Uddeholm’s range is 790 to 850°C (1450 to 1560°F). Example: 825°C (1520°F) for 20 minutes, which its table gives as approximately 65 HRC before tempering. The soak is the time at temperature “after the tool is fully heated through”: 30 minutes at 800°C, 15 minutes at 850°C. |
| Quench | Oil. The sheet names no brand and no speed. Its note: “Temper the tool as soon as its temperature reaches 50–70°C (120–160°F).” |
| Temper | Twice, with cooling to room temperature between, for at least 2 hours at temperature each time. The lowest tempering temperature is 180°C (360°F). Choose the temperature from Uddeholm’s tempering graph for the hardness you want. |
| Check | Measure a clean, properly supported test coupon after tempering. The graph was made from 15 x 15 x 40 mm oil quenched samples, and the sheet warns: “Lower hardness can be expected after heat treatment of tools and dies due to factors like actual tool size and heat treatment parameters.” |
The detail to pay attention to
The four producers agree on the shape and differ on the numbers, so pick one sheet and keep its numbers together. Hardening: Uddeholm 790 to 850°C, BÖHLER and Industeel both 780 to 820°C, Carpenter 1450 to 1500°F (788 to 816°C). Soak: BÖHLER 15 to 30 minutes and Industeel 30 minutes after equalising, Carpenter 5 minutes per inch of thickness once the work matches the furnace colour. Uddeholm and Industeel also allow a salt bath, and BÖHLER limits its salt bath and oil to sections up to 20 mm. A supplier’s sheet (New Jersey Steel Baron’s) specifies a medium-speed oil such as Parks AAA and says “Parks 50 is not recommended”; none of the four producers names an oil brand.
Keep the tang shoulders smooth and remove drilling burrs before hardening. If a file cuts the surface after the quench, first establish whether it is cutting decarb. Grinding the whole blade thinner to chase an unexplained file result can leave very little stock when the underlying steel is finally exposed.
Check the result before fitting the handle
Clean scale and decarburisation from the test surface before interpreting a hardness reading. Use a flat, supported area and a calibrated method appropriate to the sample thickness. A file skating across a blade is a rough check, not an HRC measurement.
Inspect the tempered blade in good light for cracks, edge waves and distortion. If a blade is cracked, retire it. If hardness is unexpectedly low, check the whole record before increasing temperature or repeating a quench.
Keep a record
Keep the stock supplier and batch, blade and edge thickness, furnace program, actual hold, oil or plate details, cold-treatment branch and temper cycles beside the editable design. Add measured hardness and where it was measured.
After grinding and sharpening, evaluate the finished knife in its intended cutting work. Keep notes on edge stability, sharpening and geometry. Change one main variable so you can tell what helped as you learn.
Where this comes from
- Uddeholm Arne data sheet, edition 11, 04.2019, Uddeholm. The producer’s own sheet for an oil-hardening tool steel it lists as “AISI O1, W.-Nr 1.2510”. Producer data. Tempering is given as a graph, so no tempering hardness is quoted here.
- BÖHLER K460 data sheet, BÖHLER (voestalpine). The producer’s own sheet. It says K460 “corresponds to the material 1.2510 (100MnCrW4, O1)”. Producer data; the tempering chart is a graph.
- O1-2510 data sheet, July 2023, Industeel (ArcelorMittal). The producer’s own sheet for AISI O1, W 1.2510. Producer data; the tempering curve is a graph.
- CarTech O1 data sheet, Carpenter Technology. The producer’s own sheet for AISI Type O1. Its tempering chart is linked from the PDF, not in it, so no tempering temperatures are taken from it.
- O1 Heat Treat, July 2020, New Jersey Steel Baron. A supplier’s schedule for O1, not a producer’s. Larrin Thomas advises caution with this supplier’s datasheets, so it is a comparison here and not the route.
Comments
Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.
Loading comments…