Learn / Heat treating

Heat treating D2

D2 has been a mainstay in knives for decades, and it still turns up in custom and production knives alike. It is more demanding than the carbon steels: a furnace that holds close to 1900°F, a plate quench and a cold treatment.

Knife Templates · 4 min read

Where I would start

A high-carbon, high-chromium tool steel. At about 12% chromium it is not stainless: Carpenter says only that its chromium gives "mild corrosion resisting properties in the hardened condition." The comparison with 154CM is blunt: the two have similar toughness and edge retention, but 154CM is stainless.

The route for D2, PSF27 and CPM-D2, which have the same composition, so their heat treatment is very similar. The temperature sweep was on PSF27. It uses a cold step. Carpenter's own data sheet describes a different route, covered in the catch below.

Get the equipment ready

A furnace that holds about 1900°F (1038°C), a stainless wrap or other protection for the hold, quench plates, liquid nitrogen or dry ice for the cold step, and a checked tempering oven.

Measure the furnace and tempering oven independently where possible. A controller display is a setpoint, not proof that the whole blade has reached it. Timing a hold starts after equalisation, not as soon as the door closes.

A process to work from

Use this as a complete route to establish on a coupon from your stock. Temperatures in Celsius are rounded conversions of the Fahrenheit setpoints. A different supplier, section or starting condition can need a different process.

D2: worked heat-treatment route
StageWhat to do
PrepareFinish the profile, holes and burr removal while soft. Leave measurable cleanup stock on the faces and edge.
Austenitise1850 to 1900°F (1010 to 1038°C) for 30 minutes. The recommended heat treatment is 1850-1900°F for 30 minutes, a plate quench, a cold step and a temper at 300-500°F. Without a cold step, stay at 1850 to 1875°F.
QuenchPlate quench, which is good for maintaining flatness while being plenty fast enough for good hardness.
Cold stepLiquid nitrogen or dry ice, straight after the quench, for no longer than it takes the knife to reach the cold temperature. 30 to 60 minutes is sufficient.
Temper300 to 500°F (149 to 260°C), depending on the hardness you want. A standard temper of two 2-hour cycles works just fine. The standard route, 1850 to 1875°F with a 400 to 500°F temper, gave 60-62 Rc.

The detail to pay attention to

Do not chase hardness with heat. Keep austenitizing temperatures to no higher than 1900°F in most cases unless maximum hardness is necessary: in the PSF27 tests, 1925°F raised hardness but toughness started to nosedive. Carpenter's sheet is a different route: a hardening range of 1800 to 1875°F, a soak of 20 minutes plus 5 for each inch of thickness, an air quench, and a note of secondary hardening in the temper. Keep the two apart.

Protect the surface for the hold. Carpenter notes that D2, like all high-carbon tool steels, "is subject to decarburization during thermal processing," and says that without a protective atmosphere the tool "should be pack hardened or wrapped in stainless steel." Run a coupon first, and keep the cold step immediately after the quench.

Check the result before fitting the handle

Clean scale and decarburisation from the test surface before interpreting a hardness reading. Use a flat, supported area and a calibrated method appropriate to the sample thickness. A file skating across a blade is a rough check, not an HRC measurement.

Inspect the tempered blade in good light for cracks, edge waves and distortion. If a blade is cracked, retire it. If hardness is unexpectedly low, check the whole record before increasing temperature or repeating a quench.

Keep a record

Keep the stock supplier and batch, blade and edge thickness, furnace program, actual hold, oil or plate details, cold-treatment branch and temper cycles beside the editable design. Add measured hardness and where it was measured.

After grinding and sharpening, evaluate the finished knife in its intended cutting work. Keep notes on edge stability, sharpening and geometry. Change one main variable so you can tell what helped as you learn.

Where this comes from

  • How to Heat Treat D2, PSF27, and CPM-D2, Knife Steel Nerds. Larrin Thomas’s tests, mostly on PSF27, with one recommended route for all three because they share a composition. The article states no composition; the figures on this site come from Carpenter’s data sheet.
  • CarTech No. 610 (D2) data sheet, Carpenter Technology. The producer’s own nominal composition, annealing and hardening figures for D2. Producer data, and a different route from Larrin Thomas’s: it hardens at 1800 to 1875°F and quenches in air.
Next upHeat treating Nitro-VNitro-V: the equipment, hardening hold, quench, temper and details that are easy to miss.

Comments

Questions, corrections and what worked for you. Upvote comments you find useful.

Loading comments…

Knife Templates